4 Abstract The present study examines the legal and theoretical implications of the economic exploitation of personal data within contemporary digital economies, addressing the phenomenon as a paradigmatic transformation of the relationship between person, market, and legal categories. At the core of the analysis lies the tension between the traditional conception of personal data as an expression of individual identity and their increasing treatment as resources capable of economic exploitation and contractual exchange. The first part develops a conceptual reconstruction of personal identity within private law, situating it within the broader framework of the theory of legal goods. The right to personal identity, originally shaped through judicial elaboration and later grounded in constitutional principles, is examined as a value that encapsulates the integrity and authenticity of the individual in social life. In this perspective, personal data emerge not merely as information, but as fragments of identity that contribute to the construction of the person both in the physical and in the digital sphere. The analysis then turns to the crisis of classical legal categories, showing how the notion of “thing” and the traditional model of property prove inadequate to account for immaterial, relational, and dynamic entities such as data. This leads to a reconsideration of the concept of legal goods, no longer confined to material objects, but extended to encompass resources that derive their relevance from their functional role within economic and technological systems. The second part addresses the phenomenon of the exchange between personal data and digital services, interrogating its possible qualification as a contractual relationship. The study critically examines the idea that personal data may constitute a performance susceptible of economic evaluation, capable of serving as consideration in contractual exchanges. Particular attention is devoted to the distinction between consent as a manifestation of informational self determination and consent as a contractual element, emphasizing the conceptual and normative implications of their overlap. The revocability of consent, a cornerstone of data protection law, is analyzed in relation to the stability of contractual relationships, revealing a structural tension between the logic of fundamental rights and that of market exchanges. Furthermore, the thesis explores the issue of unfair commercial practices in data driven transactions, highlighting the ambiguity of the notion of gratuitous digital services and examining the system of remedies available to users through both public enforcement mechanisms and private law instruments. The third part focuses on contracts for the supply of digital services in which no monetary price is paid, proposing a systematic interpretation of these agreements within the framework of private law. 5 The analysis considers various classificatory models, including barter, service provision, and mixed contractual schemes, ultimately arguing for a flexible approach based on the criterion of functional prevalence. The role of consumer law is examined in depth, with particular regard to the recent European regulatory developments that recognize the economic relevance of personal data without fully resolving their legal qualification. In this context, the thesis questions the identification of the weaker party in digital transactions and reflects on the adequacy of existing protective mechanisms. Across its three parts, the thesis advances the idea that personal data occupy a dual position within the legal system. On the one hand, they remain inseparably linked to the person, embodying a core of rights that cannot be fully alienated without undermining human dignity and autonomy. On the other hand, they operate as resources within the data economy, subject to processes of circulation, valuation, and exchange. This duality challenges the coherence of traditional legal frameworks and calls for a reconfiguration of the relationship between private law and fundamental rights. Ultimately, the study argues that the commercialization of personal data cannot be understood solely in terms of market logic, nor can it be reduced to the paradigm of rights protection. Rather, it requires a theoretical synthesis capable of integrating the normative demands of personal dignity with the structural realities of digital capitalism. In this sense, the law is called not merely to regulate existing practices, but to shape the conditions under which the digital identity of the individual is constructed, negotiated, and protected in contemporary society.
La commercializzazione dei dati personali come nuovo modello di business / Galliani, S.. - (2026 Jul 17).
La commercializzazione dei dati personali come nuovo modello di business.
galliani stefania
2026-07-17
Abstract
4 Abstract The present study examines the legal and theoretical implications of the economic exploitation of personal data within contemporary digital economies, addressing the phenomenon as a paradigmatic transformation of the relationship between person, market, and legal categories. At the core of the analysis lies the tension between the traditional conception of personal data as an expression of individual identity and their increasing treatment as resources capable of economic exploitation and contractual exchange. The first part develops a conceptual reconstruction of personal identity within private law, situating it within the broader framework of the theory of legal goods. The right to personal identity, originally shaped through judicial elaboration and later grounded in constitutional principles, is examined as a value that encapsulates the integrity and authenticity of the individual in social life. In this perspective, personal data emerge not merely as information, but as fragments of identity that contribute to the construction of the person both in the physical and in the digital sphere. The analysis then turns to the crisis of classical legal categories, showing how the notion of “thing” and the traditional model of property prove inadequate to account for immaterial, relational, and dynamic entities such as data. This leads to a reconsideration of the concept of legal goods, no longer confined to material objects, but extended to encompass resources that derive their relevance from their functional role within economic and technological systems. The second part addresses the phenomenon of the exchange between personal data and digital services, interrogating its possible qualification as a contractual relationship. The study critically examines the idea that personal data may constitute a performance susceptible of economic evaluation, capable of serving as consideration in contractual exchanges. Particular attention is devoted to the distinction between consent as a manifestation of informational self determination and consent as a contractual element, emphasizing the conceptual and normative implications of their overlap. The revocability of consent, a cornerstone of data protection law, is analyzed in relation to the stability of contractual relationships, revealing a structural tension between the logic of fundamental rights and that of market exchanges. Furthermore, the thesis explores the issue of unfair commercial practices in data driven transactions, highlighting the ambiguity of the notion of gratuitous digital services and examining the system of remedies available to users through both public enforcement mechanisms and private law instruments. The third part focuses on contracts for the supply of digital services in which no monetary price is paid, proposing a systematic interpretation of these agreements within the framework of private law. 5 The analysis considers various classificatory models, including barter, service provision, and mixed contractual schemes, ultimately arguing for a flexible approach based on the criterion of functional prevalence. The role of consumer law is examined in depth, with particular regard to the recent European regulatory developments that recognize the economic relevance of personal data without fully resolving their legal qualification. In this context, the thesis questions the identification of the weaker party in digital transactions and reflects on the adequacy of existing protective mechanisms. Across its three parts, the thesis advances the idea that personal data occupy a dual position within the legal system. On the one hand, they remain inseparably linked to the person, embodying a core of rights that cannot be fully alienated without undermining human dignity and autonomy. On the other hand, they operate as resources within the data economy, subject to processes of circulation, valuation, and exchange. This duality challenges the coherence of traditional legal frameworks and calls for a reconfiguration of the relationship between private law and fundamental rights. Ultimately, the study argues that the commercialization of personal data cannot be understood solely in terms of market logic, nor can it be reduced to the paradigm of rights protection. Rather, it requires a theoretical synthesis capable of integrating the normative demands of personal dignity with the structural realities of digital capitalism. In this sense, the law is called not merely to regulate existing practices, but to shape the conditions under which the digital identity of the individual is constructed, negotiated, and protected in contemporary society.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


