This doctoral dissertation investigates the role of professionalism within employment relationships in Italian public administrations, with particular attention to its relevance in determining the content of the employee’s contractual obligations. The research stems from the observation that, over the last decades, professionalism has progressively acquired a central position within the legal regulation of public employment. This trend emerges in several areas, including workforce planning, recruitment procedures, personnel classification systems, career advancement mechanisms, performance evaluation, remuneration policies, and continuing professional development. Such developments raise a broader theoretical question: whether professionalism should still be regarded merely as a personal attribute of the employee or, rather, as an element capable of affecting the legal structure of the employment relationship itself. The study addresses this issue through a systematic analysis combining labour law theory, public employment regulation, collective bargaining, and recent legislative and policy reforms. The first chapter reconstructs the evolution of the concept of professionalism within labour law scholarship. It highlights how professionalism has gradually moved beyond its traditional understanding as a protected personal interest or as a by-product of job classification systems, becoming increasingly connected to the qualitative dimension of the work performance owed by the employee. Building on this theoretical framework, the second chapter examines the main institutions governing public employment. Particular attention is devoted to workforce planning, recruitment procedures, competence-based selection methods, personnel classification systems, professional families, career progression mechanisms, assignment of managerial and organisational responsibilities, performance management systems, and the exercise of managerial powers, including ius variandi. The analysis shows that contemporary public employment law increasingly relies on competences, skills, and professional capabilities as key criteria for managing human resources. At the same time, significant tensions remain, especially regarding the broadening of classification systems and the predominantly formal interpretation of the principle of equivalence of duties adopted by courts. The third chapter explores the relationship between professionalism, remuneration, training, and public interest. It argues that professional development is no longer merely an individual concern of the employee but also a strategic organisational resource. In particular, training policies, performance-related remuneration, and competence development initiatives demonstrate how professionalism contributes to enhancing administrative capacity and improving the quality of public services. Nevertheless, the dissertation rejects any attempt to identify professionalism directly with the public interest or to transform public employment into a fundamentally different contractual model from private employment. The research ultimately argues that professionalism cannot be regarded as an autonomous asset directly constituting the object of the employment contract, nor can it be understood as altering the traditional contractual cause of the employment relationship, which remains based on the exchange between work and remuneration. However, it also challenges approaches that treat professionalism as entirely external to the contractual framework. The central conclusion is that professionalism increasingly contributes to shaping the concrete content of the employee’s work obligation. Rather than constituting a separate contractual object, professionalism operates as the qualitative dimension of the work performance owed by the employee. In public employment, this phenomenon is particularly evident because the professional capabilities of public servants are progressively integrated into systems of recruitment, classification, evaluation, remuneration, and training. As a result, professionalism emerges not merely as a personal characteristic of the worker but as a legally relevant component of the employment relationship itself. From this perspective, the dissertation proposes an interpretative framework capable of reconciling the contractual nature of public employment with the organisational and institutional functions performed by public administrations. The growing importance of professionalism does not undermine the unity of subordinate employment as a legal category; rather, it highlights the need to reconsider the role of professional competences in defining the content and execution of work obligations within contemporary public organisations.

PROFESSIONALITÀ E RAPPORTO DI LAVORO NELLE PUBBLICHE AMMINISTRAZIONI / D'Oro, A.. - (2026 Jul 17).

PROFESSIONALITÀ E RAPPORTO DI LAVORO NELLE PUBBLICHE AMMINISTRAZIONI

d'oro
2026-07-17

Abstract

This doctoral dissertation investigates the role of professionalism within employment relationships in Italian public administrations, with particular attention to its relevance in determining the content of the employee’s contractual obligations. The research stems from the observation that, over the last decades, professionalism has progressively acquired a central position within the legal regulation of public employment. This trend emerges in several areas, including workforce planning, recruitment procedures, personnel classification systems, career advancement mechanisms, performance evaluation, remuneration policies, and continuing professional development. Such developments raise a broader theoretical question: whether professionalism should still be regarded merely as a personal attribute of the employee or, rather, as an element capable of affecting the legal structure of the employment relationship itself. The study addresses this issue through a systematic analysis combining labour law theory, public employment regulation, collective bargaining, and recent legislative and policy reforms. The first chapter reconstructs the evolution of the concept of professionalism within labour law scholarship. It highlights how professionalism has gradually moved beyond its traditional understanding as a protected personal interest or as a by-product of job classification systems, becoming increasingly connected to the qualitative dimension of the work performance owed by the employee. Building on this theoretical framework, the second chapter examines the main institutions governing public employment. Particular attention is devoted to workforce planning, recruitment procedures, competence-based selection methods, personnel classification systems, professional families, career progression mechanisms, assignment of managerial and organisational responsibilities, performance management systems, and the exercise of managerial powers, including ius variandi. The analysis shows that contemporary public employment law increasingly relies on competences, skills, and professional capabilities as key criteria for managing human resources. At the same time, significant tensions remain, especially regarding the broadening of classification systems and the predominantly formal interpretation of the principle of equivalence of duties adopted by courts. The third chapter explores the relationship between professionalism, remuneration, training, and public interest. It argues that professional development is no longer merely an individual concern of the employee but also a strategic organisational resource. In particular, training policies, performance-related remuneration, and competence development initiatives demonstrate how professionalism contributes to enhancing administrative capacity and improving the quality of public services. Nevertheless, the dissertation rejects any attempt to identify professionalism directly with the public interest or to transform public employment into a fundamentally different contractual model from private employment. The research ultimately argues that professionalism cannot be regarded as an autonomous asset directly constituting the object of the employment contract, nor can it be understood as altering the traditional contractual cause of the employment relationship, which remains based on the exchange between work and remuneration. However, it also challenges approaches that treat professionalism as entirely external to the contractual framework. The central conclusion is that professionalism increasingly contributes to shaping the concrete content of the employee’s work obligation. Rather than constituting a separate contractual object, professionalism operates as the qualitative dimension of the work performance owed by the employee. In public employment, this phenomenon is particularly evident because the professional capabilities of public servants are progressively integrated into systems of recruitment, classification, evaluation, remuneration, and training. As a result, professionalism emerges not merely as a personal characteristic of the worker but as a legally relevant component of the employment relationship itself. From this perspective, the dissertation proposes an interpretative framework capable of reconciling the contractual nature of public employment with the organisational and institutional functions performed by public administrations. The growing importance of professionalism does not undermine the unity of subordinate employment as a legal category; rather, it highlights the need to reconsider the role of professional competences in defining the content and execution of work obligations within contemporary public organisations.
17-lug-2026
38
Dottorato di Ricerca in Persona, Mercato, Istituzioni
RESCINITI, Riccardo
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12070/77326
 Attenzione

Attenzione! I dati visualizzati non sono stati sottoposti a validazione da parte dell'ateneo

Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact